Claims Litigation

Everyone who has represented a general unsecured creditor in a big chapter 11 case has had this experience. After the proof of claim has been filed, and usually after the plan has been confirmed, you receive in the mail the “Reorganized Debtor’s First Omnibus Objection to Claims.” Attached to the objection is an exhibit listing, in very small type, literally hundreds of claims. The grounds for objection may be something like “required documentation not attached.” Unless a timely response is submitted, all of these claims will be disallowed.

If you have defended a few preference actions, I’ll bet that you’ve heard this one from your client more than once: “Can I countersue them for what they owe me?" The obvious (to a bankruptcy lawyer) and correct response is “no,” but you might not have been 100% glib if called upon to explain why. Now the Ninth Circuit has come to your rescue, and you can just say “In re Adbox, Inc., 2007 WL 1584582 (9th Cir. June 4, 2007).