Low Threshold Adopted for “Participation” Sufficient to Bind a Credi...

By: Jonathan Weiss

St. John’s Law Student

American Bankruptcy Institute Law Review Staff 

In S. White Transportation, Inc.,[1]the Bankruptcy Court for the Southern District of Mississippi held that secured creditor had “participated” in the chapter 11 case and was bound by a plan voiding its lien because it received notice, even though it had not appeared or taken any action in the case.[2] The debtor, S. White Transportation, Inc. (“SWT”), had challenged the validity of a Deed of Trust with the creditor, Acceptance Loan Company, Inc. (“Acceptance”) in state court on the basis that the individuals who had signed the Deed of Trust on behalf of SWT did not have the authority to do so.[3]  Consistent with its claims in state court, SWT’s proposed chapter 11 plan classified Acceptance’s lien as a disputed claim on which no payment would be made.[4] Two weeks after SWT’s chapter 11 plan was confirmed, Acceptance objected to the plan, requesting that the court find that its lien survived the confirmation unaffected.[5] The court held that the plan voided the lien and denied motions for relief and modification of the plan, and reaffirmed the old adage that litigants must not “sleep on their rights”.[6]

read more